I had the privilege of hearing Dr. Hickerson deliver a keynote address on the ethical and societal impact of deepfakes at a recent technology conference. I asked her for an interview, and she was kind enough to oblige. ~ Paul Chaney
TL;DR
In this interview, Dr. Andrea Hickerson, Dean of the School of Journalism and New Media and Professor of Journalism at the University of Mississippi, explored the ethical and societal impacts of deepfakes and AI on marketing and journalism.
She emphasized the importance of transparency, consent, and trust in content creation, highlighting how deepfakes challenge traditional notions of truth and authenticity.
Dr. Hickerson argued that existing ethical principles, like trust and veracity, still apply to AI-generated content and that the primary responsibility lies in ensuring audiences are not deceived.
She also detailed her team’s ongoing work on a deepfake detection tool, stressing the need for regulatory oversight and consumer protections, especially as AI technology becomes increasingly sophisticated and influential.
Main Talking Points
1. Primary Ethical Concerns
The core ethical issues surrounding deepfakes in marketing and journalism are accuracy, trust, and consent. Without clear disclosure, audiences might be misled, eroding trust.
2. Disclosure and Audience Relationship
The context of content matters; different mediums have distinct audience expectations, such as fictionalized movies versus factual marketing. For marketing, subtle disclosures (e.g., “created with AI tool”) could help maintain transparency.
3. Existing Ethical Principles
Dr. Hickerson emphasized that while new policies may not be necessary, core values like trust, transparency, and consent should guide AI’s ethical use. These values can be applied to evolving technologies like AI and deepfakes.
4. Challenges of Deepfake Detection
Detecting deepfakes is complex and ongoing as adversarial technologies evolve. Dr. Hickerson’s interdisciplinary team, supported by a $2 million NSF grant, focuses on creating fact-checker detection tools.
5. Regulatory Oversight and Public Trust
Regulatory clarity is needed, though challenges include varied global and state regulations. Dr. Hickerson suggested that consumer protections should prioritize minimizing harm, with public trust as the ultimate benchmark for ethical AI practices.
6. Market-Driven Changes
While formal regulations develop, organic changes may drive ethical practices as companies strive to retain consumer trust and maintain transparency in AI-generated content.
7. Consumer Empowerment
Dr. Hickerson encouraged consumers to engage critically with AI content, fostering an informed public capable of navigating this rapidly advancing technology landscape.
Taking a Deeper Deepfake Dive
Authenticity is a prized commodity in today’s digital world. The rapid advancement of AI and deepfake technologies is forcing marketers and content creators to rethink what it means to engage responsibly.
As you delve deeper into this evolving landscape, one thing becomes clear: ethical principles like transparency, trust, and consent are more crucial than ever. But what does that mean for you, and how can you ensure your AI-driven content doesn’t jeopardize the trust you’ve worked hard to build?
Understanding the Ethical Concerns
Deepfakes — blending audio and visual content to create hyper-realistic but fake media — raise complex ethical questions, particularly around accuracy, trust, and consent. Imagine this: your audience sees what appears to be a genuine video or endorsement. But unless you disclose it’s AI-generated, you risk misleading them. Even if the intent is harmless, undisclosed deepfakes can create a breach of trust.
The relationship you have with your audience defines their expectations. For example, movies with CGI don’t need disclaimers, as audiences understand they’re fiction. However, in marketing, people expect honesty, especially when real people, emotions, or facts are depicted. Without transparency, you may inadvertently manipulate their perception, damaging your brand’s credibility.
The Importance of Disclosure and Context
Context matters more than you might realize. If you’re using AI-driven content in an ad, subtle cues like “created with [AI tool]” or “paid actor” can make all the difference. Maintaining a clear, authentic relationship with your audience means giving them the information they need to make informed decisions about your brand and its message. If you’ve always used factual content, suddenly presenting deepfakes without disclosure may feel like a betrayal, breaking your cultivated trust.
Applying Time-Tested Ethical Principles to AI
The good news is you don’t need entirely new ethics to address AI-driven content. Traditional values like transparency, trust, and consent remain foundational. By approaching AI-generated content with these principles, you can prevent a “Wild West” situation where the technology leads, but ethics lags. As AI becomes more integrated into marketing, leaning into these shared ethical boundaries ensures you’re compliant and trustworthy.
Deepfake Detection and Responsibility
If you’re exploring or even cautious about using deepfakes, consider the ongoing efforts to keep up with this technology. Teams like Dr. Hickerson’s are advancing deepfake detection tools to help audiences, journalists, and fact-checkers identify manipulated content. While detection is improving, adversarial tech continues to push the boundaries, making it crucial for marketers to remain vigilant about the source and integrity of their AI-driven content.
Navigating Regulatory and Market-Driven Changes
The regulatory scene is still evolving. While Europe leads in developing AI regulations, you may face a patchwork of different standards across states or countries. However, market incentives may soon encourage ethical practices. Imagine losing your audience’s trust because of a poorly disclosed deepfake — a real possibility that could make ethical transparency a competitive edge.
As Dr. Hickerson highlights, public trust is the ultimate benchmark. If consumers feel deceived, they may abandon your brand altogether. Building and maintaining trust, especially in AI, requires keeping your audience’s best interests in mind. Ensure your practices align with their expectations, and when in doubt, disclose the origins of AI-generated content.
Empowering Your Audience with AI Literacy
As AI becomes mainstream, don’t underestimate your audience’s ability to understand and engage critically with AI-driven content. People want to know the truth behind the information they consume. By being open about your technology, you empower your audience, encouraging them to be informed consumers. This transparency isn’t just ethical; it enhances your credibility and deepens their trust.
Incorporating AI and deepfakes into your marketing strategy doesn’t mean compromising your values. You can create engaging content that resonates without risking your brand's integrity with transparency, respect for your audience, and a commitment to existing ethical principles. As AI shapes the future of marketing, let trust and authenticity guide your steps.
Like what you read? Share your thoughts and opinions about the ethical impact of deepfakes in marketing.
Share this post