California's AI Laws and Their Impact on Marketing Ethics

California’s AI regulations set a new benchmark for transparency, safety, and accountability, reshaping marketing ethics and influencing AI governance across the U.S. Not everyone is on board.

California's recent passage of several AI regulatory bills has sparked a nationwide conversation about the future of AI governance. These laws, including the Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier Artificial Intelligence Models Act and the California AI Transparency Act, set new standards for AI safety, transparency, and accountability. As other states begin to follow suit, these regulations are poised to reshape the landscape of AI development and marketing ethics across the United States.

Photo source: Pymnts

The federal government has made little effort to regulate AI, so it’s been left to the states to enact their own laws and regulations. California has taken up the challenge and is leading the effort. The California legislature recently passed several key bills to regulate artificial intelligence:

SB 1047: Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier Artificial Intelligence Models Act

SB 1047 requires large AI companies to test systems for safety before public release and allows the state attorney general to sue for damages if technologies cause significant harm.

• Scope: It applies to AI models that require more than $100 million in data to train, a threshold that few current models meet but could become more common as the technology evolves.

• Controversy: The bill has been contentious, with some arguing it targets developers rather than those who misuse AI. Amendments addressed industry concerns, including removing a proposed new agency dedicated to AI safety and narrowing liability provisions to punish companies only for actual harm, not potential harm.

SB 942: California AI Transparency Act

SB 942 mandates that covered providers with over 1 million monthly users offer free AI detection tools and include disclosures on AI-generated content.

• Key Provisions:

  • AI Detection Tools: Must be publicly accessible and allow users to assess whether AI created or altered content.

  • Manifest Disclosures: Providers must offer users the option to include a watermark or other disclosure on AI-generated content.

  • Latent Disclosures: AI-generated content must include hidden information about its provenance, which free tools can detect.

• Penalties: Violations can result in civil penalties of $5,000 per violation, collected through civil actions filed by the Attorney General, city attorneys, or county counsels

Other Bills

• AB 2013 requires developers to disclose information about data used to train generative AI systems by January 1, 2026.

• SB 926 and SB 981 address misuse of AI-generated deepfakes and digital identity theft.

These bills aim to enhance transparency, safety, and accountability in AI development and use. Governor Newsom has signed several laws, with decisions on SB 1047 and AB 2013 pending by September 30, 2024.

Impact on Marketing Ethics

The recently passed California AI regulatory bills significantly impact AI marketing ethics in several ways:

1. Transparency in AI-Generated Content

Because SB 942 mandates that covered providers offer AI detection tools at no cost to users and include visible and latent disclosures in AI-generated content to indicate its provenance, it ensures that consumers are aware when interacting with AI-generated content, promoting trust and ethical marketing practices. It helps prevent deception and allows users to make informed decisions about the content they engage with.

2. Data Transparency

By mandating transparency in AI training data, AB 2013 addresses issues of bias and ensures fairness in AI algorithms. It also helps protect consumer privacy by giving users more control over their personal data and how AI systems use it.

3. Ethical Considerations

By requiring transparency in AI training data, these laws aim to address issues of bias and ensure fairness in AI algorithms. This promotes ethical AI development and deployment, which is essential for ethical marketing practices.

4. Compliance and Accountability

These laws establish a regulatory framework that encourages responsible AI use and holds developers accountable for the impacts of their AI systems and companies for their AI practices. Violations can result in civil penalties, such as $5,000 per violation, emphasizing the importance of compliance.

In summary, the legislation impacts AI marketing ethics by promoting transparency, addressing bias, enhancing consumer protection, and enforcing accountability in AI development and use. This sets a precedent for ethical AI practices and encourages businesses to prioritize transparency and responsibility in their AI applications.

---

Please like, comment on, and share this post. Your support helps us in the Substack rankings and allows more people to learn about AI marketing ethics. We’re counting on you!

---

What People Are Saying

The tech world is sharply divided over the passage of these laws and regulations.

According to Axios, Anthropic has offered cautious support for the bill following certain changes, while OpenAI opposes it, saying it could "stifle innovation."

Elon Musk said Monday that California "should probably pass the SB 1047 AI safety bill," arguing that AI's risk to the public justifies regulation. "This is a tough call and will make some people upset," he said.

Coursera co-founder Andrew Ng said, “Right now, I’m deeply concerned about California's proposed law SB-1047. It’s a long, complex bill with many parts that require safety assessments, shutdown capability for models, and so on.”

Nancy Pelosi, vocal in her opposition, labeled the bill as "well-intentioned but ill-informed" and argued that it could harm California's tech industry by imposing burdensome regulations.

What’s your opinion? Leave a comment.

---

Inspiration for Other States

The comprehensive nature of California's AI regulations positions them as potential templates for other states and the federal government. Given California's history of regulatory leadership and significant economic influence, particularly in the tech sector, these laws could set a national precedent.

The absence of federal AI legislation further amplifies the importance of California's initiatives, as other states may look to adopt similar measures. This trend is already evident, with states like Colorado and Utah enacting their own AI laws, focusing on consumer protection and disclosure requirements.

As the AI regulatory landscape evolves, California's approach may shape the future of AI governance across the United States.

As of February 7, 2024, 407 AI-related bills have been introduced across 41 U.S. states, with 211 introduced in January 2024 alone. This surge in state-level AI legislation reflects growing concerns about AI governance. Key areas of focus include:

Deepfake regulations. Thirteen states have passed laws regulating AI use in political advertising, and at least 18 more are considering similar bills.

Task forces and advisory councils. Twenty-two states have established groups to study AI regulation and use.

Election-related AI legislation. States like Alabama, Arizona, Florida, Idaho, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Texas, Utah, Washington, and Wisconsin have passed laws addressing AI in elections.

---

Takeaways

California’s AI laws are more than just state-level initiatives; they catalyze change in AI governance nationwide. For marketers, these regulations underscore the importance of ethical AI practices—transparency, fairness, and accountability are no longer optional but essential. As AI continues transforming industries, marketers must stay ahead by adopting these principles and ensuring compliance with emerging regulations.

Don’t wait for federal legislation to catch up. Take action now—evaluate your AI systems, implement transparent practices, and ensure your marketing strategies are aligned with the latest regulatory standards. Lead the charge in ethical AI marketing and build trust with your audience today.

These resources can help…

What’s your take? Let us know in a comment.