This issue features an interview with Peter Mullen, Chief Marketing Officer of Interactions, a technology company focused on AI automation in customer service and CX. The conversation covered AI's impact on customer service, its ethical challenges, and the role of regulation and industry self-governance in ensuring ethical AI deployment.
Main Takeaways
AI in Customer Service:
AI is transforming customer service through automation, providing efficiency and reducing human jobs.
Generative AI, like ChatGPT, can offer personalized services but raises ethical concerns about transparency and data privacy.
The use of deepfakes and synthesized voices makes distinguishing between human and AI interactions harder.
Ethical Challenges:
Transparency is crucial for building trust with customers by disclosing AI interactions.
Bias is currently not a major issue in customer service AI but could become more significant as technology advances.
Data privacy is a significant challenge, with AI systems capable of compiling detailed user profiles quickly.
Regulation and Self-governance:
Government regulation is necessary but often lags behind technological advancements.
Industry self-governance, through third-party validation, can help ensure ethical AI use.
Learning from EU regulations around data privacy provides a model for ethical AI deployment.
» » Check out our Resources page for more information about AI ethics. « «
Peter Mullen Interview
This is an AI-assisted redaction of the interview. Listen to the audio recording to hear the full version.
Q: What ethical issues arise from using AI agents in customer service or customer experience?
PM: Conversational AI agents represent a company's brand and voice. This raises trust and transparency issues, such as disclosing that it’s an AI agent interacting with the customer. Responsible use of customer data is crucial to prevent misuse and bias, requiring guardrails to be established.
Generative AI like ChatGPT can offer personalized services but raises ethical concerns about transparency and data privacy. Deepfakes and synthesized voices also make distinguishing between human and AI interactions harder.
Q: How does the AI industry impact through things like automation relate to ethics?
PM: AI is driving major efficiency gains and job losses in customer service, highlighting workforce impacts and income inequality issues. Companies must balance efficiency with ethical considerations. Generative AI offers significant operational efficiency, which is attractive to businesses looking to trim costs, often equating to human headcount reductions. This efficiency, however, must be managed ethically.
Q: How do issues like transparency, data privacy, trust, and bias specifically apply in your industry?
PM: Transparency about AI identity is essential for building trust. While data privacy rules are established, new risks emerge as AI systems share data across digital borders.
Currently, bias is not a major issue in customer service AI, which lags behind other applications. However, the potential for bias exists, and it's crucial to address it proactively. We make it clear to customers that they are interacting with an AI system by using phrases like “I am an automated attendant.”
Q: How do regulatory bodies like HIPAA and PCI interface with AI in your industry?
PM: Regulations like HIPAA and PCI shape what data can be collected and used. At Interactions, we adhere to strict data privacy practices, but regulations often lag behind AI capabilities. The evolving nature of AI requires continuous updates to regulatory frameworks to ensure they remain relevant and effective.
Q: What will it take to rein AI in — government, industry self-regulation, or both?
PM: Global alignment is emerging on the need for intelligent guardrails and regulation. Biden’s executive order provides a good framework, but third-party validators are needed to deploy these rules effectively. Regulation alone cannot keep pace with technological advancements; industry self-governance through third-party validation is also crucial.
Q: Looking ahead, what do you see on the horizon for AI ethics issues in marketing and customer service?
PM: AI will be the most disruptive technology ever, surpassing the internet and vaccines. It brings huge opportunities but requires adapting. Companies need help understanding the ethical implications.
The ethical challenges of AI include balancing operational efficiency with job preservation, ensuring transparency and trust in AI interactions, protecting data privacy, and preventing bias. These issues will become increasingly prominent as AI becomes more integrated into customer service.
Q: Can you provide examples illustrating risks around AI bias?
PM: While bias is not a major issue in customer service AI today, there are potential risks. For instance, AI systems might develop biases based on data they are trained on. An example could be an AI system identifying certain customers as 'difficult' based on their interaction history and treating them differently. It's important to address these potential biases before they become problematic.
Q: How is Europe ahead of the U.S. on AI regulation?
PM: Europe, with regulations like GDPR and the efforts of organizations like OECD, has been more proactive in protecting individual rights in the digital age. These regulations provide a model for the U.S. and other countries to follow. The EU's approach to data privacy and AI ethics serves as a benchmark for creating a balanced regulatory environment.
Q: What is the "AI priest" example?
PM: The AI priest is an example of how AI can be used unexpectedly and potentially controversially. A digital priest offering confessions raises significant ethical questions about the appropriateness and reliability of AI in such sensitive roles. This example highlights the need for careful consideration of the ethical implications of AI applications. (UPDATE: The Catholic church stripped him of his priestly garb.)
Q: What additional insights can you share about the future of AI and its ethical implications?
PM: AI's rapid advancement will continue to disrupt industries, requiring ongoing adaptation and ethical consideration. The key is to develop trustworthy and reliable AI systems that align with ethical principles. As AI technology evolves, so must our approach to its regulation and governance. The collaboration between government, industry, and third-party validators will be essential in navigating the ethical landscape of AI.
Peter Mullen - Chief Marketing Officer, Interactions
Peter Mullen brings more than two decades of marketing leadership to his role as Interactions’ CMO. Previously, he was Senior Vice President of Marketing at Payactiv, leading customer success marketing, lead-gen programming, customer acquisition, product marketing, and more. Before that, he held prominent marketing and communications roles at VXI Global Solutions, Comcast, and Netflix.
This Week in AI Marketing Ethics
How Generative AI Is Changing Customer Service (AIthority)
The Evolution of AI in Customer Service: What’s Next? (CMSWire)
Ethical Considerations in Using AI to Predict Customer Behavior (The Good Men Project)
How Klarna is using AI for cost savings (Digiday)
2 in 5 customers are concerned about AI ethics (MarketingTech)
Ethical Challenges in AI-powered Customer Service